The NICI Newquay review: A taste of the Amalfi Coast in Cornwall?
October 29, 2026

[Disclosure: I stayed at the NICI Newquay for a hotel review for a newspaper, but have also written about it here. I was also invited to the spa for the purposes of this blog, so I’ve combined everything in this post.]

If you mention Newquay, people will undoubtedly have some kind of view on how it’s not as nice as other places in Cornwall, full of stag dos, blah blah blah.

Those people are wrong. Or at least outdated.

Yes, parts of Newquay are slightly less salubrious than some of Cornwall’s towns and villages. It’s also still a popular party town to a certain extent, but nothing on the scale it was. And in recent years, it’s levelled up hugely when it comes to food, drink, and pretty much everything, in my humble opinion.

Boutique shops, award-winning bars and restaurants – including one with a Michelin star (not that that is the be-all-and-end-all but in this context the fact Ugly Butterfly is in Newquay and thriving kind of adds to my point), good pubs, and plenty more. All set against the backdrop of some brilliant beaches and a vibrancy that comes with it being a ‘real’ place that still has people there in the winter, despite the general mass exodus you often in lots of parts of Cornwall.

With all that in mind, it’s perhaps no surprise that the NICI hotel brand chose Newquay for its first Cornish outpost.

The NICI Newquay

Perched above Great Western Beach in the former Hotel Victoria, the big old seaside venue was given a full-on spruce up, transforming into what the company calls a slice of the Amalfi Coast on the Cornish coast. It’s certainly an impressive place to visit, and nobody can argue it isn’t great to have something like this in Newquay, hence the huge fanfare when it opened in summer 2026.

So… did it deliver, or was it all style and no substance?

First impressions of The NICI Newquay

As mentioned, the building itself is an impressive old place when you first pull up. Which you can do right outside thanks to valet parking which instantly makes the whole experience feel a bit elevated. Rocking up, not having to worry about a parking space and simply handing over your keys then skipping off to fun times feels pretty lovely and adds to that luxury feel.

As you walk through the doors, you definitely get the Mediterranean look and feel they’re trying to create. Bowls of lemons, glossy coffee-table books, statement chandeliers dangling down the centre of the traditional seaside hotel staircase, all mixed in with relaxed coastal styling that very much reminds you that you’re still in Cornwall.

The NICI Newquay
NICI Newquay interior
NICI Newquay interior

Head through the sprawling lounge/bar/restaurant area and onto the terrace and you’ve got another pièce de resistance thanks to its views and vantage point. At some point there will also be an outdoor pool, so this really will be an al fresco haven, but even the terrace as it is is undoubtedly a selling point for a drink, lunch, or dinner on a warmer evening.

You don’t quite get an uninterrupted sunset that’s often the draw to Cornwall’s north coast, but it’s still a pretty special spot. While it might be a bit breezy in cooler months, I spotted some firepits that would warm you on a chilly evening. And if you don’t, there are plenty of corners in the lounge and bar area to cosy up in. Not to mention bench seating on landings and elsewhere to pause and take a breath at any point of the day.

Reception is available for pretty much anything you need, from booking spa treatments and dinners, to activities out on the beach, or asking about some of the family-friendly options like the indoor cinema room or other activities.  It’s worth noting that the NICI is a really easy walk into town, so if you want to explore and try some of the other restaurants and bars, it’s nice and easy. Close to the train station too, if you’re coming from further afield and without a car.

Rooms at The NICI Newquay

The rooms themselves are more of that Amalfi-meets-Cornwall feel. Ours opened out onto a shared balcony with sort-of sea views (albeit across a big old flat roof and separated from next door’s section by a small screen – bear that in mind if it’s privacy you’re after, and book a room with a private balcony).

Inside, bold lemon-inspired upholstery continued a taste of Italy, while a surfboard on the wall added a dash of Cornwall. There were all elements you’d expect from a high end hotel – robes, coffee machine, lush toiletries, and all that jazz.

Bedroom at the NICI Newquay

Bedroom at the NICI Newquay

There are a few extra things that add to the luxury feel – the most special of which is probably the drinks trolley offering complimentary gin if you fancy a tipple but can’t be bothered to leave the room. Then there are the practical touches too, like USB sockets, sensor lights inside cupboards and a few extra seats. Not quite a suite, but I think a seating area is always a bonus in a hotel room.

Safe to say, we had a stunning night’s sleep and the rooms definitely feel a cut above your average hotel room – testament to the interior design and decor, especially when newly opened.

Bedroom at the NICI Newquay

The spa at The NICI Newquay

The hotel itself would be impressive enough thanks to the way it’s been renovated and all the things earlier in this blog. But the spa is definitely a bit of a highlight – adding to the experience and making the NICI a daytime destination even if you’re not staying overnight.

Tucked underneath the restaurant and bar area, it has its own heated indoor swimming pool with windows looking out to the sea, along with hydrotherapy pool, sauna and steam room. There are treatment and relaxation areas and the massage I had there was genuinely up there with one of the better ones I’ve had in a hotel.

The custom blend massage is all about tailoring it to you and what you reckon you need, so you get to choose your oil and then enjoy a body full body massage, focusing on any niggles you might have and with general relaxation in mind. Afterwards, the relaxation room with its low lighting and comfy cuddle chairs is the perfect place to recline together, or alone.

The NICI Newquay spa

It’s worth mentioning that the gym at the NICI is much better equipped than most. I may be in the minority here, but the fact that so many hotel’s promise a ‘gym’ then actually deliver a treadmill, bike and three dumbbells is a bit of a bugbear of mine. Not so here, with a decent selection of cardio equipment and weights machines, along with free weights. Great if having a good workout is part of your idea of having a good time.

Spa at the NICI Newquay

Spa at the NICI Newquay

What can you do at The NICI Newquay?

The short answer is ‘loads’.

As mentioned, there are complimentary activities on offer during your stay, including surf lessons and beach yoga, and they’ll organise things like boat trips for you. There’s a kids’ club and a private cinema for any rainy afternoons.

If organised fun isn’t for you, or lounging in the spa, then it’s an easy walk to explore Newquay. Or you could just soak up the hotel itself – sitting on the terrace on a sunny day enjoying the view, snuggling up in the lounge, or just luxuriating in your room or on the balcony.

Obviously the beach is just below, with others not far away, so you can soak up having it all on your doorstep. There’s plenty to do and see, and as much or as little as you like. That’s the joy of it.

Food and drink at The NICI Newquay?

The hotel’s main restaurant, Amalfi’s, continues the Italian theme. The dining room is sprawling and, as mentioned, the terrace is pretty special.

On the menu you’ll find Italian-inspired dishes from pasta and pizza to seafood and meat-focused mains. A NICI caesar salad is made tableside for a bit of theatre, while a mushroom fettucine comes finished in a pecorino wheel for a similar sense of fun.

Amalfis NICI Newquay
Amalfis NICI Newquay
Amalfis NICI Newquay
Amalfis NICI Newquay

Our visit was soon after opening, so the restaurant experience wasn’t quite as slick as some other parts of the operation, but I figure that’s forgivable in the early days of a fairly big operation with a new team. Small hiccups like a side being substituted for something else without us being told, and the pecorino pasta coming on a plate rather than served from the big wheel we were waiting for – apparently more due to a breakdown in communication as if you’ve ordered outside (where we started) you get it like this rather than in the wheel. Seagulls and all that.

Amalfis NICI Newquay

Despite this, the food for the most part was pretty good. I’ve since been back for lunch and the tableside caesar salad was a  decent experience, done nicely.

Breakfast, too, was an enjoyable affair. The morning saw the lengthy bar transformed into a buffet breakfast of dreams. Pastries, bread, cereals, fruit, yoghurt, meats, cheeses and all the usual bits you suddenly feel compelled to eat simply because you’re staying in a hotel. Bring on breakfast pudding, I say!

On top of that, there’s a menu of cooked dishes, from a full Cornish breakfast to eggs Benedict and other classics. Shakshuka was well executed – a big portion, packed with a touch of spice and heat, and presented nicely. Enough to convince me that I think these guys will get to grips with a fairly good food offering given time.

Breakfast at The NICI Newquay
Breakfast at The NICI Newquay
Breakfast at The NICI Newquay
Breakfast at The NICI Newquay

 

So, is The NICI Newquay worth it?

Yes, I’m inclined to say it probably is. Is it at the higher end of the price bracket? Yes. But does it feel like a cut above your average seaside hotel? Yes, absolutely.

The interior is beautiful, as is that terrace, and the spa is pretty lovely too. The outdoor pool will be a gorgeous addition, and I think there may be talk of the food offering expanding too. All this means it has the feeling of a pretty grand hotel, kind of holiday resort, right in the middle of Newquay and quite a bit more high end than lots of places.

Plus, let’s not forget the fact that Newquay itself has a tonne to offer in terms of decent food and drink experiences, gorgeous scenery, and more.

Yes, there were teething problems when we went, but the service was pretty marvellous, the rooms lovely, and the experience itself really quite lovely. And I just think you can’t deny that having this level of investment in a place is a good thing, and something that will benefit far more people than the customers who check in. And for those who do, they’re in for a pretty good time.

I stayed at The NICI for the purposes of a review. As always, all views are my own.

Pinterest
LinkedIn
Share
Instagram