Review: The perfect lunch at Argoe, Newlyn
November 20, 2026

[Disclosure: We paid in full for our lunch at Argoe in Newlyn. Well, Jamie did since it was my birthday]

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. Some meals just stick with you. The food, the place, the service, yes. But also the moment when reality doesn’t just live up to expectation, but exceeds it. That joyous feeling of something panning out exactly as you’d imagined and hoped, and that feeling of your heart being as full as your belly as you waddle out the door.

For me, celebrating turning 44 at Argoe in Newlyn was one of those. I’ve wanted to go for some time, but despite my many occasions of waxing lyrical about how good it could be, it took a video from the Fallow Chefs on YouTube to prompt Jamie to book a table for a birthday lunch. Mildly frustrating but I’m not one to cut my nose off to spite my face, so off we willingly went.

Argue Newlyn
Happy lady on terrace

If you haven’t heard of Argoe, it’s nestled right on the harbour in Newlyn. And if you haven’t heard of Newlyn, it’s home to one of the largest fishing fleets in the UK. Newlyn sits between Penzance and Mousehole and if you’re in that area you should definitely visit, even if it’s just to mooch past the many places selling fish hauled out of the sea that day. Not to mention some great eateries serving up that fish. I’m a big fan of Mackerel Sky Seafood Bar, but there are plenty more – and I feel a guide to restaurants, cafes and bars in this area coming up soon on this blog.

Back to Argoe. Look for a pretty, box-like building right next to the harbour, literally feet from the sea. It’s not huge, but has indoor space as well as some lovely outdoor terraces that are dog-friendly and covered in case the Cornish rain comes blowing in mid-meal.

Our visit is on a quietish Thursday in September, through there’s a nice mix of people, including two elderly couples luxuriating in a celebratory 60th anniversary lunch for one of them – a treat from their children, and quite franklyI can’t think of a better treat to mark such a milestone. Since treats are on the agenda, we start with a bpottle of Cava kindly sent from afar from our best pals. Something different from the usual fizz offerings on restaurant menus, and part of a drinks menu that includes orange wine as well as the standard white, red and rose, as well as a few cocktails and aperitifs from both Cornwall and further afield.

The food is an array of dishes that aren’t formally divided into starters, mains and desserts, but listed simply alongside an explanation from the incredibly capable front of house staff. A few little nibbles if you fancy at the start. Small snack-like dishes. Slightly bigger plates. And then the show stopping whole fish for the table. Plus sides to go with them.

There are no rules. No expectations on whether you head straight for a big old fish cooked over fire, or stick to the small plates. Or do everything, like we plan to. Because that’s what you do on a birthday, or in fact on any day you fancy.

First up is a fresh, citrusy salpicon made from crayfish (or crawfish – which one do we say? Either way, those freshwater crustaceans that are a bit like prawns and, let’s be honest, once they’re cooked and peeled and dressed like this is, most of us mere mortals probably wouldn’t know the difference). It’s fresh, light and tasty and works as well on a slightly blustery September day as it would on a hot July one. The citrusy dressing also serves to limber up the tastebuds ready for the many other things that come one by one, filling our table with as much food as joy.

Fish dishes at Argoe Newlyn

I’m reticent to order fried squid, because everywhere does fried squid and I’m kind of over it. But Jamie’s reasoning is that this will be a real test – basically he wants it to be the best fried squid he’s ever had, and he declares it is. The batter’s light and fresh, the tender and soft. Rubberiness begone, this is how fried squid should be served.

Smoked pollack and potatoes is my favourite. Laced with dill, the flakes of smoked fish are mixed into a creamy dressing with potatoes that, yes, actually taste of potato. Sounds bonkers, but I’m sure you know what I mean. It’s also a reminder that it’s not just the fish that’s sourced from about as close as it can get, but the veg and produce too.

Potato dish

Clams and beans remind me of being in Spain somewhere tucking into a a hearty seafood dish in a casual bar somewhere, as does a dish of runner beans and Ajoblanco. In fact, there are plenty of nods to Spanish food culture, from Catalan Almonds to pan con tomate. The runner bean dish also serves as a reminder that veg should sometimes be allowed to be the star of the show rather than a bit part. Like me with the squid, Jamie had been reticent to dedicate one of our choices to something that he wasn’t sure would shine as brightly as some other fish-focused dishes, but I’m happy to say he was wrong. The beans themselves have that lovely taste of earthy ‘greenness’, emphasised by the nutty, savoury Ajoblanco.

Clams and beans
Runner beans dish
Dishes on plate

 

It’s a smorgasbord of delights showcasing the best of the fruits of the sea and land. We could order more. Hand dived scallops call out to us, as does a Tomatillo salsa that the Fallow boys rave about on their video. But we’re saving space for what we’ve decided is the main event. One of the whole fish that you can order for your table, cooked over fireThe showstoppers at Argoe are whole fish, cooked simply over fire. Because when fish is this fresh, it needs very little messing with.

On the day we visit the choice is John Dory, Seabass and Monkfish. We go for the first – a fish we’re probably least familiar with. But the thing about Argoe is you can’t really help but trust them once you’ve tried the food. I saw another review describe it as “an everything’s-going-to-be-ok kind of place” and it resonated with me. It’s the kind of place you’ll order something new, do things a bit differently, and know that it’s going to be okay because of the comfortable control that oozes from the moment you walk in.  Whether that’s explaining the menu, dealing with a far-flung friend’s remote request to produce a bottle of fizz as soon as you sit down, dealing with dogs, suggesting amounts, orders and explaining fish. It all comes with a sense of calm and self-assurance that puts you at ease.

Terrace overlooking harbour
John Dory on a plate

The John Dory’s great. Cooked simply with that slight smokiness of charcoal that gives way to the sweetness of the fish. The flesh is delicate but still has a tasty firmness. We have it as it is. No sides needed, because quite frankly we’ve had plenty and it just doesn’t need anything to distract from it. It’s a double-edged sword really. I now love John Dory but am too nervous to try it elsewhere in case that’s as good as it gets.

When it comes to the meal, we decide that this isn’t the case so in the quest to make it even better, order a chocolate mousse, espresso and dessert cocktail. Because that’s how pros finish good meals in my humble opinion. The chocolate’s gorgeously, bitterly rich, topped with toasted nuts and a drizzle of very good olive oil. The coffee’s strong, the negroni even stronger. And for about the fourth year running I declare it my best birthday yet.

Chocolate dessert
Dessert at Argoe Newlyn

Jokes aside, Argoe was everything I’d hoped it would be and everything everyone said it was. It’s not just the food. Obviously when you take great fish, caught within hours in some cases, then cook it well, it’s going to be great. But there’s something about the spot, the way the menu’s put together, and the service, that create a rather lovely experience. Long may it last.

Pinterest
LinkedIn
Share
Instagram